SF TV Episode Reviews: Space: 1999, episode 2, ‘A Matter of Life and Death’ (1975)

5/10 (Average)

Continuing my nascent series of episode by episode blog posts of Space: 1999 (1975) I present Episode 2, season 1 ‘A Matter of Life and Death.’

Plot Summary (spoilers — inherent in the very nature of this sci-fi episode post series because endings are the easiest to rant about)

Moonbase Alpha, hurtling across space, comes into contact with its first potentially inhabitable planet — Terra Nova. Koenig sends an Eagle space craft down to the surface to investigate.  When it returns the two pilots are alive but unconscious and a third body, Doctor Helena Russell’s husband Lee (presumed to be long dead in an expedition to Jupiter), is found!

The chief scientist, Victor Bergman (Barry Morse), is unable to record Russell’s life signs (it’s somewhat annoying that Bergman does all the medical related research while Helena Russell is supposedly the chief medical officer).  When Lee Russell finally wakes up he only wants to speak to his wife.  Bergman discovers that Lee Russell is drawing Helena’s life force when they are alone to sustain his body.

When interviewed, Lee is unable to fully explain his the dangers presented by the planet Terra Noval to the crew and soon “dies.”  A scan is done of Lee’s “dead” body which uncovers a “reversing polarity” of his skin – i.e. he’s turning into antimatter.

This discovery isn’t enough to discourage Koenig’s expedition down to the planet.  On the planet they discover “pure water” (which is brown — hmmm) and various edible plants (the set is only a slight improvement from the barebones planetscapes of TOS).

However, the tranquility and excitement of these discovers are tempered by disaster!  The corrosive atmosphere is melting all the seals on the Eagle spacecraft.  Everyone starts dying — and then, Lee Russell reappears!  And rolls back time…

Final Thoughts

‘A Matter of Life and Death’ is a poor follow-up to the top-notch pilot, ‘Breakaway‘.  The main flaw is the dependence on an extraordinarily hokey ending to tie up the shamble of the plot — in short, everything can be fixed if we roll back time since we kind of had to kill off all the characters because we didn’t know what else to do!

I’ve always been frustrated with sci-fi episodes/films which rely on killing off characters indiscriminately before brining them back to life (for example, TOS movies).  Firstly, it shows an inability to create necessary tension.  Secondly, if a character has that sort of power the power could be harnessed for a vast variety of purposes which would defeat the existence of the show’s plot — the fact that Moonbase Alpha has been detached from orbit and is hurtling across space.  Why isn’t time rolled back even farther to prevent that catastrophe?

If we’re dealing with these sorts of annoying “super powers” they have to be tempered by at least pseudo-scientific ramblings.  Because there’s no attempt to do so in ‘A Matter of Life and Death’ life and death are trivialized…

The cinematography, Moonbase Alpha’s wonderful 70s aesthetic, hilarious action sequence music, and interesting sets barely prop up this poor episode.

If only the creators had stuck to the original homage to Stanislaw Lem’s Solaris script…

In case you missed earlier posts:

List of Episode Reviews

5 thoughts on “SF TV Episode Reviews: Space: 1999, episode 2, ‘A Matter of Life and Death’ (1975)

  1. Well, in this case I think it had more to do with the fact that her husband was the one being treated… they did multiple tests on him behind her back because they were worried about her reaction/and obviously how her relationship might skew various her actions — I won’t make a stronger statement about women as doctors in 70s sci-fi until I watch more episodes of the show.

  2. I had to laugh outloud at your spoiler warning. Too bad about the episode though…perhaps better luck with episode 3? And I agree with you about the time rolling plot device–pretty weak script writing.

  3. It’s TRUE! Endings are the easiest thing to rant about! And yes, time rolling the plot back a few hours/minutes has an “honoured” place in the highest pantheon of horrible plot devices…

    Yeah, hopefully they do get better — I haven’t mustered the fortitude to watch the next episode, yet…

  4. I watched these as a kid and grew up wanting to be an eagle pilot?!

    scared to go back to the flared trousered travelers and finding out it was not as brilliant as i thought.

    so for now, they remain boxed and hidden.

Comment! Join the discussion!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.