Book Review: The Quality of Mercy, D. G. Compton (1965)

4/5 (Good)

D. G. Compton’s first science fiction novel, The Quality of Mercy (1965), is a forgotten work which deserves to be read along with the rest of his canon.  I’ve found Compton’s lesser known works to be on the whole quite solid — with the dismal The Missionaries (1972) the lone exception so far.  Both Synthajoy (1968) and The Steel Crocodile (1970) are among my top reads of this year.  I’m keeping his acknowledged masterpiece The Unsleeping Eye (1974) till later.

The Quality of Mercy manages to create a viable husband and wife team whose evolving relationship is the main motivating force of the novel.  Somewhat falsely described as having “the same terror-probability quality as Dr. StrangeloveThe Quality of Mercy instead focuses on the breakdown of a single family extrapolated from the extension of Cold War areas of operation a few years into the future.  Thankfully a plot along the lines of “will the bomb be dropped or not” à la Lumet’s Failsafe is not the source of tension — instead, moral questions are posed of Donald’s covert operations and other questionable actions by his wife Maria with catastrophic (and disturbed) consequences.

Brief Plot Summary (substantial spoilers)

A few years from today (1965) the world has become increasingly overpopulated.  A virulent and mysterious disease VPD kills indiscriminately or so it seems.  Donald, an Englishman, flies covert “peacekeeping” operations over Western Europe from a secret base in England staffed predominately by Americans.  However, the real purpose of the flights is known only to an elite few.  The base personel are completely in the dark as to the real point of the missions and spin wild ominous rumors about the disease, the operations, etc.

The base Squadron Leader presents Donald’s wife Maria with information about the flights — Donald at various points doesn’t believe him, Donald doesn’t want to believe him, and eventually decides that national security is more important.

Approaching the base one night Donald and his wife are stopped by protesters.  The protesters have a young woman dying if VPD with them — they beg Donald to take the girl to the doctors at the base.  Donald refuses because there’s no cure.  The situation becomes more dire when the protesters attempt to stop the cae and Donald throws a gas grenade.  Later, it is discovered that the girl died faster than the normal course of the disease because of the gas.

The flight information supplied by the Squadron Leader, the governmental cover-ups, Donald’s questionable moral decisions, comes to head in the person of Maria, who confronts him…

Final Thoughts

Strong female characters? Yes. Disturbing ending? Yes.

I’ve found that Compton is one of the best 60s/70s male writers when it comes to creating female characters.  The reader roots for Maria and is devastated by Donald’s final actions.  Although her role is ostensibly that of a housewife, she is more intelligent than Donald, has a stronger moral makeup, and the only redeemable character (a case can be made for the unnamed Squadron Leader).

The “mystery” isn’t exactly a mystery but that’s fine because the characters are the focal point of the work.

The Quality of Mercy is a quality Cold War related science fiction novel, well-written, and engaging.  Sadly it is seldom read….  Hopefully my review will convince a few to procure a copy.

More Book Reviews

4 thoughts on “Book Review: The Quality of Mercy, D. G. Compton (1965)

  1. I just might have to pick this one up. Sounds very interesting. Kind of eerie from your description of the plot how Compton seemed to be telling the story of a events that sound almost like true to life ones. The disease, overpopulation… Sometimes art does mimic real life.

  2. I’ve been going through Compton’s work recently, having previously only read The Continuous Katherine Mortenhoe, and it’s shame that such a good writer with such a strong handle of prose and good ideas has only been recognised within the sf community for that one work. Synthajoy and The Steel Crocodile are excellent reads and I think this will have to be next.

    • Hello Alex, he received the Cordwainer Smith Rediscovery Award for this very reason! One of the few authors who received the award who was still alive.

      As I reviewed this novel way back in 2011 (when I was only in my early 20s) I wonder what I would think about it now. I’m not sure it’s close to the level of Synthajoy and The Continuous Katherine Mortenhoe — but if you already enjoy his work it’s probably worth the read.

Comment! Join the discussion!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.