My “to review” pile is growing and my memory of them is fading… hence short—far less analytical—reviews.
1. The Ballad of Beta-2, Samuel R. Delany (1965)
(Vincent Di Fate’s cover for the 1982 edition)
3.25/5 (Vaguely Good)
As I’ve been on a generation ship kick as of late, I was excited to pull out my copy of Samuel R. Delany’s early novel The Ballad of Beta-2 (1965). Delany subverts the standard (and infuriating) trope of cultural stasis—for the sake of societal stability—that authors suggest will occur between the colony ship’s departure and arrival. Instead, Delany explores the intermediary generations by examining a series of ballads that harbor deep secrets.
The novel’s basic premise is a seductive one: Vast generation ships set off to colonize an alien world. After their departure, humankind discovers FTL travel. The generation ships arrive only to find the planet already settled. In orbit, the surviving degenerate colonists still reside in their massive spacecrafts. The wreckage of another destroyed ship orbits with them. A youthful anthropology student, tasked with investigating the surviving literary works of the Star Folk dismissed by previous scholars as uninteresting drivel, sets off to learn more from the survivors who created the Ballad of Beta-2. He discovers that the imagery and metaphors of the poem hint at the “true” history of the voyage—and the awesome implications of an alien creation.
The underlying premise—and exploration of the cultural production of a generation ship crew—is rarely touched upon in the subgenre. That said, the titular ballad whose meaning is unpacked over the course of novel, is a poor piece of literature. It’s visually awkward and not compelling enough to frame the entire story.
I found The Ballad of Beta-2 one of the few Samuel R. Delany novels that falls flat. Babel-17 (1966), published the following year, showed more of Delany’s immense potential. Recommended for his fans and those craving an inventive approach to the basic generation ship story.
(Davis Meltzer’s cover for the 1975 edition)
(Ed Valigursky’s cover for the 1965 edition)
(Kelly Freas’ cover for the 1971 edition)
2. The Last Transaction, Barry N. Malzberg (1977)
(Ron Walotsky’s cover for the 1st edition)
3.25/5 (Vaguely Good)
Between 1968 and 1982, Barry N. Malzberg produced an intoxicating corpus of often nihilistic/metafictional science fiction black comedies. Returning to his work feels like returning to a special corner of a bookstore—I know Malzberg’s tricks and tendencies. I know the language of the erotic will be repurposed for disquieting un-erotic discourses on the machine age and mental vastation unleashed after JFK’s assassination on Americans (the death of idealism, the death of political trust, the death of “truth”). The Last Transaction (1977) creates yet another existential nightmare—the “erotic” and senile ramblings of an ex-President, desperate to disgorge his last verbal vomit before death.
The Last Transaction deploys an effective structure—the jumbled meandering memories of a ex-President descending into senility. His memories, mostly of the sexual nature (but also the failure of his first marriage, the untimely death of his son, his second marriage to a far younger woman, and a national crisis), converge on his failed reelection campaign of 1984. The inclusion of a brief biographical blurb, like what you would find in an encyclopedia, for President William Eric Springer (birthdays, wives, dates elected to office), provides the necessary framework into which plunge headlong into the nightmare. At turns hilariously funny–the President, his feet propped up on a pillow, mumbling his last words into a recording device, while his nurse and his doctor allow the media in to ogle—and uncomfortably empty (Springer doesn’t seem to stand for anything as an elected official), this feels like a descent into madness. A sifting through of useless yet self-defining memories….
If you’re new to the bleak black comedies of Malzberg, The Last Transaction is not the place to start. There’s a sharpness missing, a loss of enthusiasm, a reluctance to experiment–it lacks the metafictional touches that elevate novels like The Men Inside (1973). It all feels a bit tired. The idea between other projects? Or, perhaps the novel’s shock value, the disgraceful/empty last thoughts of a president, has lost its power in the era of Trump.
For Malzberg completists only.
Start with Beyond Apollo (1972), The Falling Astronauts (1971), or Herovit’s World (1973).
3. A Time for Survival, Philip McCutchan (1966)
(Uncredited cover for the 1st edition)
2.75/5 (Vaguely Average)
The year is 1975/1995 (two dates are given), the Chinese with their Soviet allies engage in open nuclear warfare with the UK and their American allies. Johnny and Anna Clayton and their newborn son Mike survive the nuclear attack in a government fallout shelter. Mr. Clayton’s metallurgic research (skills needed if Britain is going to remake its weapons and warships upon reemergence!), confers him and his family VIP status. With the rest of their shelter blasted into smithereens, the family treks for London–he needs to report to Command!
They encounter a racist sailor named Blacker, and partially due to the 25-year age difference between Anna and Johnny, a lot of sexual tension transpires…. Blacker gives Anna a mirror. She says it’s the best gift ever. McCutchan, who wrote primarily military fiction, unsurprisingly creates horrid female characters. Imagine Cormac McCarthy’s The Road (2006) but on the A3 between Portsmouth and London—but without all the gorgeous language and sheer visceral terror.
A Time for Survival treads similar ground to John Christopher’s The Death of Grass (1956). While Christopher posits an almost instantaneous reversion to survival of the fittest, McCutchan suggests the slide into primitive barbarity for individuals will be slow–of course they are but caught in the middle of the faceless entities of the Cold War power blocs. I found McCutchan’s theory on human nature a far more believable one—good people will eventually, as the true nature of their destroyed world sinks in, resort to evil. That said, unlike Christopher’s far superior contemporary A Wrinkle in the Skin (variant title: The Ragged Edge) (1965), McCutchan’s prose is possessed by a banal economy of language and vision. There are no evocative sequences of devastation. No surreal moments encountering the traumatized. It is relentlessly bland.
Only recommended for die-hard fans of 60s post-apocalyptic fiction.
Note: Sorry about the poor quality of the above cover. The internet does not seem to know the book exists–no Goodreads votes and very few covers. My edition is a cast-off from the Montreal City Library. Between 1971 and 1976 it was checked out 10 times. As it is a library book, it came without a dust jacket.
For book reviews consult the INDEX
For cover art posts consult the INDEX
13 thoughts on “Short Book Reviews: Samuel R. Delany’s The Ballad of Beta-2 (1965), Barry N. Malzberg’s The Last Transaction (1977), and Philip McCutchan’s A Time for Survival (1966)”
#1 Fifty-five-plus years ago (when it was written), so I’m not too surprised the ballad wasn’t great. I can’t remember if he’d met Marilyn Hacker by then.
#2 Oh dear gawd NO. Reagan made me queasy as I watched him slide into dementia; 45 is almost unendurable already.
#3 …but it had a Second Impression…it even says so!
I wish I read The Ballad of Beta-2 as a young adult — I would have loved it! One of the better Ace Double volumes though….
Elements of the Malzberg novel remind me of ideas that Trump might have on his deathbed (the self-obsession, etc.). That said, Malzberg’s president at least appears to have some level of empathy. Malzberg’s president is a tool — he does neither good nor bad (there appears to be only one crisis during his presidency which he accidentally defuses). He’s a political nonentity who does all the correct things to win the presidency. A far less terrifying individual than our current one….
I didn’t like “The Ballard of Beta-2” and don’t even remember what it was about, but I wasn’t keen on “Nova” either. I preferred his “Babel-17” and “The Einstein Intersection”.
I was tepid on Ballad as my review hopefully made clear. I’ve read Nova twice but that was almost a decade ago so I remember little.
Yes, it did. I had high expectations of “Nova”, but I didn’t find it impressive and can’t remember anything about it.
I’ve only read a few of Delaney’s shorts, and managed about 200 pages of Dhalgren before I put it aside–though I might add I liked what I read of Dhalgren, I just didn’t pick the book up again soon enough and now so many years have passed…
I’ve been planning on reading Nova for a while now and have heard it’s great/good/ok.
Malzberg has yet to grab me. I read Beyond Apollo and liked it, but… maybe I’ve read too many metatextual novels, mostly non-sf, and find their appearance in sf not without interest, but, but. I’ll have to ponder this some more. I enjoyed the short A Galaxy Called Rome. And I am keen to read Malzberg’s Herovit’s World.
I think you should try more Malzberg — I’m biased of course! He’s a favorite.
Perhaps explore one of his America post-JFK vastation type novels that engage with media and the debunking the cult of the astronaut — like Revelations (1972): https://sciencefictionruminations.com/2012/08/27/book-review-revelations-barry-n-malzberg-1972/
Or the sculpted nightmare world of The Gamesman (1975): https://sciencefictionruminations.com/2014/07/09/book-review-the-gamesman-barry-n-malzberg-1975/
Note: A lot of people recommend Herovit’s World so I did as well. I’m personally not the biggest fan of it. I do not think there are any SF elements (it’s about a SF writer).
Both of those sound very interesting. Tho i have to say my chief focus in sf is before the experiments in literary “decomposition” of the 60s and 70s (lets say 1945-1965 to be slightly arbitrary!). Which is not to say i’m uninterested in such experiments.
I need to read some Sheckley to get me back in the mood for SF from that era. I’ve been mostly fascinated by the 70s as of late.
Bought a bunch of books on 60s radicalism — I seem like I’m entrenching in my decades. Hah.
1) James Miller’s Democracy Is in the Streets: From Port Huron to the Siege of Chicago
2) Rebecca E. Klatch’s A Generation Divided: The New Left, the New Right, and the 1960s
3) Arthur Marwick’s The Sixties: Cultural Revolution in Britain, France, Italy, and the United States, c.1958-c.1974
4) Jeffrey Jacob’s New Pioneers: The Back-To-The-Land Movement and the Search for a Sustainable Future
The Arthur Marwick looks very interesting. Not sure why I haven’t stumbled across this before. On 1968 in France I can recommend Michael Seidman’s “The Imaginary Revolution”. An excellent book.
At first glance the Marwick is appealing as it tries to tackle the movement outside of the US as well — I am also intrigued by a British historian’s take on the American counterculture.
My copy of Jeffrey Jacob’s New Pioneers: The Back-To-The-Land Movement and the Search for a Sustainable Future arrived! Look forward to diving in.
Regrettably, the only Malzberg I’ve read so far were a couple of books co-written with Bill Pronzini. I’ll have to give his solo stuff a try.
Thanks for visiting!
I’m a huge, unabashed, proponent of Malzberg’s experimental/black comedy/nihilistic visions.
Would you prefer reading short fiction or novels? I’ve reviewed a bunch of both on this site.
I talk about his astronaut novels in this article from a few years back: https://sciencefictionruminations.com/2013/01/14/sci-fi-article-barry-n-malzberg-b-1939-metafiction-and-the-demystification-of-the-cult-of-the-astronaut/