Harry Harrison and Gordon R. Dickson’s The Lifeship (1976) is two parts tense and exciting adventure in the expanse of space and one part half-hearted “key differences between individuals are overcome in the end” attempts at social commentary. I found the first two-thirds of the work riveting. Sadly, the final third devolves into a ramshackle and unpleasant mixture of save the world formulae and endless exposition at gunpoint about all the nefarious nooks and crannies of each and every plan, counter-plan, potential plan, half-realized plan, and unrealized plan soon to be fomented in the liminal realm of coalescing plans.
At points in the narrative Dickson’s delightful ability to portray alien societies pokes through. Thankfully the work avoids anthropology lectures on the alien Albenareth who remain tantalizingly enigmatic and original. Not having read any of Harry Harrison’s other works I can’t zone in on specific aspects of his style — hopefully it’s not the muddle of the last third.
Brief Plot Summary (limited spoilers)
The Albenareth are an enigmatic alien race that considers space travel a religious experience. To die in space is the ultimate honor. Time served in space transporting other races adds to that honor. They provide their expertise of space travel to humanity which does not have the technology yet has the massive natural resources to build and repair their ships. However, the Albenareth are a decadent species whose spaceships, spacesuits, and societies are slowly crumbling as more and more seek a life (and death) in space.
Giles Steel, our human main character, is a member of the highest strata of human society. Most of humanity lives in a form of indentured servitude reinforced by genetic tinkering. Giles slowly comes to appreciate the lower levels of society as the novel progresses.
The novel opens with a massive explosion on an old Albenareth transport vessel. Giles Steel, seven indentured humans, and two aliens escape in an Albenareth lifeship. The lifeship maintains oxygen and supplies food by means of growing vine inside the vessel (not as weird as the alien seedpod spaceships in Aldiss’ The Dark Light-Years). The Albenareth captain and engineer sequester themselves in the front of the vessel leaving Giles Steel and the other humans in the back.
Soon various revelations are uncovered: a) Giles Steel’s mission, before the explosion on the transport ship, was to assassinate his one-time friend Paul (the leader of a radical revolutionary group seeking rights for the indentured), b) Giles planted the bomb but the explosion wasn’t supposed to destroy the ship, c) one of the indentured humans is a cop, d) the female Albenareth captain doesn’t mind dying in space as they eventually get to their destination and by that point everyone would have run out of food…
Giles Steel is an interesting character. He’s a onetime revolutionary who has since forsaken his earlier desire to free the indentured majority of humanity. However, over the course of the dangerous voyage on the lifeship he comes to appreciate the indentured as fellow adults instead of children or “lads.” The social commentary comes off as forced and the simplicity of this sort of race analysis is out of place in a late 70s work.
The other slowly coming to an understanding plot thread is between Giles and the Albenareth captain. Giles, as the as the high class representative of the humans and the only one who understands the alien’s language, must decode the alien’s society in order to navigate a cultural impasse. The Albenareth, in the overtaxed environment of the small lifeship, wouldn’t mind dying in space because she would regain the honor lost in the destruction of the transport vessel.
The Lifeship is worthwhile for fans of claustrophobic space adventures and interesting alien societies — but don’t expect a masterpiece. But, be warned — he final third is a frustrating hodgepodge of themes, abrupt revelations, silly backstabbing, and simplistic attempts at social commentary.
9 thoughts on “Book Review: The Lifeship, Harry Harrison and Gordon R. Dickson (1976)”
I read this book as a serial in Analog. I don’t recall much about it. Both Harrison and Dickson are great writers when they are on top of their games. But I suspect this book was written more as an exercise than anything else.
I can’t find evidence that it was a serial in Analog… Do you remember what year? At least not according to the publication history on isfdb.com. But yeah, feels kind of like an exercise.
Analog magazine, February through April issues, 1975. The serialized story was titled Lifeboat. https://www.dropbox.com/s/cc7xvbhj1ywjqse/27916.jpg?dl=0
Wasn’t impressed with the sole Dickson novel I’ve read (Mission to Universe) nor the only Harrison novel I’ve read (Jupiter Legacy)… wasn’t digging Harrison’s collection in Prime Number either. Not really looking forward to delving further into these authors’ works, let alone a collaboration!
I kind of liked Dickson’s The Alien Way and the premise of this sounded interesting enough. It was a fun tension filled read with some interesting aliens — with a crummy ending. The only Harrison novel I want to read is Make Room! Make Room!…
I recently read Mission to Universe and it wasn’t bad, but I probably won’t be reading any more Dickson.
I read a lot of Harry Harrison in my teens, and have good memories of the first three Stainless Steel Rat books, the three Deathworld books, the Eden books, and Bill the Galactic Hero. I recently reread the Deathworld books, and they were decent adventure stories. I haven’t read anything Harrison wrote in the last 30 years, and I have not heard good things.
Bill the Galactic Hero is a very broad satire, and I will avoid it, as I suspect I won’t like it nowadays, but I think I may reread the first few Stainless Steel Rat books, and the Eden books.
It’s been a while since I read any Harrison – High School to be specific – but I remember reading his Eden Trilogy and couldn’t get enough it. I have read some of his short stories, and well, I have to agree with 2theD, there nothing to get excited about.
Hmm, well, only if I like Make Room! Make Room! will I read anything else by Harrison…. However, I don’t dislike Dickson — yes, he might be average, but not all that horrible.
I haven’t read “Make Room!Make Room!”.I’ve just read “Captive Universe” by Harry Harrison,a 1976 Berkley paperback edition I picked up at a books for free shop.If you’ve read it,I suspect like me,you’ll think it wasn’t bad,but it was conceptually flawed and unconvicing.The premise of an Aztec culture and the breakthrough of discovery,lacks concrete conviction,and his rather cliched.
He was better staying with his more zany novels,such as “Bill the Galactic Hero” and “The Stainless Steel Rat”.